The following is a summary of the information you hear
during the trial. Based on this information, answer the question
at the bottom of the page. Although this is a hypothetical situation,
do your best to answer the question as you think you
would if you were actually a member of a jury hearing this case.

Description of the crime.
On Friday, May 6, 2005, the owner of a small grocery store was confronted
by a man who demanded money from the cash register. The owner immediately handed
one hundred dollars to the robber, who took the money and started walking away.
Suddenly, and for no apparent reason, the robber turned and fired two shots at the
owner and his five-year-old granddaughter, who was standing behind the counter.
Both victims died instantly. Two hours later, the police arrested a suspect, who was
charged with robbery and murder.

Summary of Arguments Presented by the Prosecution

• The robber was seen running into the same apartment house in which the defendant lived.
• One hundred dollars was found in the defendant's room.
• Traces of ammonia used to clean the floor of the store were found on the defendant's shoes.
• Chemical tests to determine whether a person has gunpowder on his hands from firing a gun indicated that there was a slight possibility that the defendant had fired a gun that day.
• The clerk who witnessed the crime was 75% sure that the defendant shot the person he saw shoot the two victims was the defendant.

• Five years ago, the clerk who witnessed the crime had been treated for depression in a mental hospital.
• The defendant testified that he did not commit the crime.
• The defendant testified that the money found in the room was his savings.
• The defendant testified that the ammonia traces on his shoes could have been obtained at a different place because he worked as a delivery man.
• The defendant testified that he had never fired a gun in his life.